Report: Do EU Free Trade Agreements Diversify Trade?

FTAs can broaden the range of products, but do not necessarily lead to more suppliers.

Patrik Karpaty Trade Policy Adviser

Free trade agreements can help diversify trade, but their impact differs across sectors and supply chains. A new report from the National Board of Trade Sweden examines when and how trade agreements can contribute to diversification. Author Patrik Karpaty explains.

What does the report examine?

The report examines whether free trade agreements (FTAs) can contribute to a more diversified supply of goods. We have analysed whether the agreements lead countries to import a wider range of products and source them from more suppliers outside the EU. The main case study is Vietnam, where we track developments in exports to the EU from 2012 to the present.

Why did the National Board of Trade Sweden decide to investigate this issue?

Following the pandemic, the energy crisis and rising geopolitical tensions, resilient supply chains have become a key concern. At the same time, the concept of “diversification” is used in different ways in the policy debate. We therefore wanted to examine what diversification means in practice and how trade policy – not least existing free trade agreements – can contribute.

What are the main findings of the report?

The main conclusion is that free trade agreements do not automatically lead to diversification. Effects can also vary considerably between product sectors within the same agreement. Aggregate effects are often small because positive and negative sectoral effects sometimes offset one another. This is particularly evident for Japan and Singapore.

Sweden generally follows the same pattern as the rest of the EU, although the effects are smaller. Diversification increases more in technology and chemicals, particularly in Sweden’s trade with Vietnam and Canada. At the same time, supplier concentration has remained broadly unchanged in both the EU and Sweden, with no visible break associated with any of the agreements. FTAs can therefore broaden the range of products, but do not necessarily lead to more suppliers.

Were there any results that surprised you?

Yes, two things. The first is how rapidly China’s share of the value added in Vietnam’s exports has increased – from around 3 to 6 per cent. This shows that even if production shifts to a new country, dependencies may remain further upstream in the value chain. It is therefore not always enough to look only at where a product is imported from; we need to trace value added throughout the production chain.

The second is how much the effects vary within the same agreement. An agreement can broaden the product range in one sector but have no such effect in another.

What do the findings mean?

This report only examines the role of FTAs in diversification. It does not measure other benefits, such as lower prices, clearer rules, increased foreign investment or faster growth in partner countries – effects that previous research has often identified following FTAs.

Our analysis shows that FTAs cannot be expected, on their own, to spread risks in supply chains. The range of products may broaden without the number of suppliers increasing. If policymakers want greater diversification, FTAs may therefore need to be complemented by other tools.

What other tools can policymakers use to promote diversification?

These could include incentives and better information, for example strategic raw-material partnerships, stockpiling of critical materials, recycling and circular-economy solutions, and greater transparency in supply chains. Existing FTAs can also be used more effectively through clearer rules of origin and technical assistance. Over the longer term, investment in skills and infrastructure in alternative production countries can also contribute.

What do you hope the report will achieve?

I hope it will help policymakers distinguish between different types of diversification, and see where in the supply chain the risks lie. This will make it easier to choose the right tools for the right problems. Free trade agreements are important, but they cannot solve all the problems associated with concentrated supply chains.

What is the National Board of Trade Sweden?

The National Board of Trade is the Swedish government agency for international trade, the EU internal market and trade policy. Our mission is to facilitate free and open trade with transparent rules as well as free movement in the EU internal market. We provide the Swedish Government with independent analyses, reports and policy recommendations and take into account the views of businesses of all sizes in international trade policy-related matters.